Key takeaways
As loving dog owners, we know just how difficult training a new pup can be. So, it's natural to wonder whether there are any other options to make it easier.
Dog training collars have been around for years, but not all of them are safe, and many are cruel and uncomfortable for your dog.
This is why it's essential you do your research before opting for a dog training collar. Use this complete guide to find the best solution for your canine companion.
Quick Navigation
What are dog training collars?
Types of dog training collars
**Anti-pulling collars: **These collars can come in many different forms, but most fasten around your dog's chest. This means your puppy will feel a slight pressure on their chest if they do pull on the lead, which will usually distract them from the object they were going to chase or pull towards them. Reinforcing good behavior with a treat will prevent any negative associations.
**GPS tracking collars: **Collars that come with a clip-on GPS can be a fantastic way to keep an eye on your dog if they're prone to escaping or running long distances. It can keep your mind at rest and ensure your dog stays safe wherever they are!
**Head halters: **These collars slip over the dog's nose and neck and can be very effective in reducing pulling. However, if used incorrectly, it can put strain on your dog's neck and nose, causing pain and discomfort. It's only suitable for certain puppies so ensure you get professional advice before using these.
**Bark collars: **Electric bark collars can detect the vibration of your dog's vocal chords and will send an electric shock into your dog's neck when they bark. Despite the shock often being very small, it's still a form of punishment and can cause your dog distress and pain, especially if it malfunctions.
**Shock collars: **Other collars can be linked up to a remote control so the owner can cause an electric shock to the dog when a bad behavior is exhibited. Again, this punishment can lead to further bad behavior, aggression, and upset.
**Slip collars: **These collars are made up of one long string of durable material and a metal loop, so when the dog pulls, the collar tightens around their neck. These are incredibly unsafe because there is no way to control the tightness. This can lead to damaging your dog's neck and blocking their airways.
Do dog training collars work?
Comparing the top 3 dog training collars
1. Tractive GPS Collar
Your dog's activity levels
Your dog's sleep patterns
Changes in your dog's routine
2. Rabitgoo No-Pull Dog Harness
3. PetSafe Gentle Leader
FAQs
What type of collar is best for dog training?
The best type of collar for dog training depends on what you are trying to train your dog. A gentle and comfortable harness will be best to prevent pulling, and a GPS tracker would be best if your dog tends to run away.
Is a dog training collar a good idea?
A dog training collar can be very effective and a good idea if you're struggling to control your dog. However, do plenty of research and consult with a professional to ensure you choose a safe, comfortable, and practical option.
Are shock collars banned?
Shock collars have officially been banned in the UK since February 2024. Worldwide, they are still used.
Do vets recommend training collars?
It's unlikely a vet would recommend a training collar unless you are really struggling to control your dog and it is posing a danger to the community.
Is it better to train with a collar or a harness?
A comfortable harness will help your training efforts by preventing pulling and allowing you to have more control over your dog.
Do no-shock collars work for dogs?
No-shock collars use a small vibration to distract your dog when they are about to exhibit bad behavior or if they bark.
Final thoughts
Written by
In this blog, I combine my two areas of expertise: pets and writing. I share my personal experiences alongside plenty of animal behavior research to help owners look after their pets. I have always lived with furry friends and am now a loving cat mum to two orange kitties.
